I remember, a long time ago, as a kid, I would go with my grandpa to a farmer’s market, where he would buy a couple of large, dark golden brown challahs. Back then, it was my favorite bread. It was pleasantly sweet, chewy, soft inside, and slightly crusty on the outside. I wished we would buy it every day, or even every week, but it only happened around holidays, a few times a year.
I’ve been looking for a challah bread recipe that would give me the same taste that I remember. Most challah recipes I’ve tried produce bread that is a bit, and sometimes much, too rich, too eggy, or too sweet for my taste. The one that I remember was like just slightly enriched plain white bread. It was tasty, almost too tasty; it was addictive. I liked having it with jam, butter or a few slices of sausage, or just eating it on its own.
After a lot of experimenting and reading up on old challah bread recipes, I seem to have finally come up with precisely what I was looking for. This challah tastes just like I remember it. My family loves it. I don’t think it needs any more tweaking, but feel free to experiment with this recipe to customize it to your taste. It’s big, a touch over 3 lbs after baking, but it always goes so fast. 
This Jewish bread is a looker; it’s stunning. It will be a centerpiece at your holiday table, and people will be talking about it. I love the dark color of the crust. You get that from using an egg yolk wash. If you like a lighter color, use a whole egg wash.
To make this challah bread I use a two-stage process. First, I make a poolish. The bread that utilizes poolish tends to have a richer taste and a chewier crumb. To make the poolish, I use 60% of the flour and almost all of the water, together with all of the yeast. Once the poolish is ready, doubled or even tripled in size, I mix the final dough. That’s stage two. The rest of the process is fairly typical to any bread – bench resting the dough, shaping, proofing, and baking.
I use a 6-strand braid to shape my challah. Each strand is about 14 inches, with the middles quite thicker than the ends. This allows making a plump, gorgeous looking bread.
Three- or four-strand braiding didn’t give me the plumpness that I was looking for. I keep the strands short, so I can get a stubby, plump loaf.
Here is the most helpful instruction video I was able to find on how to braid a six-strand challah. It has the right orientation so you can easily follow the instructions.
Given the sugar and the egg in the dough, baking on a stone resulted in a slightly burnt bottom. This bread comes out better if baked on a baking sheet.
To get the color and the crust I was looking for, I bake my challah bread at 450F. This seems to work quite well in my oven, but you may have to adjust the temperature as, as they say, each oven bakes differently.
Challah Bread
Ingredients
Poolish
- 600 g all-purpose flour about 4 cups, using 'scoop and swipe' method
- 400 ml water about86F/30C; about 1 3/4 cups less 1 Tbsp
- 10 g instant yeast about 1 Tbsp; also known as Quick Rise or Rapid Rise yeast
Final dough (in addition to the poolish above)
- 400 g all-purpose flour about 2 3/4 cups, using 'scoop and swipe' method
- 80 ml water 86F/30C; about 5 1/2 Tbsp
- 15 g kosher salt about 1 Tbsp
- 70 g white sugar about 5 1/2 Tbsp
- 25 g butter melted; about 1 3/4 Tbsp
- 1 egg
Eggwash
- 1 egg yolk use the whole egg for a lighter color of the crust
- 1 tsp heavy cream
Garnish
- 3 Tbsp poppy seeds
Instructions
- To prepare the poolish, mix the flour with the water, and the instant yeast. Cover and let rise in a warm place for about 2 hours, until about tripled in size. I use a cold oven with the light on, it provides a perfectly warm environment.
- Combine the poolish with the rest of the dough ingredients in a bowl of a stand mixer. Mix on low (Kitchen Aid setting 2) for 2 minutes. Cover and let rise in a warm place for about 45 minutes, or until doubled in size.
- Divide the dough into 6 equal pieces, and roll them out into 8"-10" logs. Cover and let rest for 20 minutes.
- On a lightly floured work surface (wooden is ideal), roll each log into a 14" long strand, making the ends thinner than the middles. Dust the strands with a little bit of flour to prevent sticking. Braid into a six-stranded challah bread.
- Brush with the egg wash and sprinkle poppy seeds on top.
- Bake at 450F for 25-30 minutes. Chill for one hour before serving.
Reva
Thanks for your reply
Reva
Hi can this be made the day before and put in the fridge overnight and baked the next day ?
Victor @ Taste of Artisan
Definitely, but you would need to reduce yeast. I would follow a similar approach as in my French Baguette recipe.
Andrea
Hi Victor, another great bread recipe. Though I have a favorite challah bread recipe, I like yours more. I learned a few new things from it. For example, your egg yolk and heavy cream egg wash gives the bread a much better color. Thank you and keep up the great work.
Victor @ Taste of Artisan
You are welcome, Andrea. Happy baking and thanks for your feedback.